My Reaction to The Bachelorette Finale

If you, like me, watched the finale of The Bachelorette last night and had TOO MANY THOUGHTS, you may be able to relate to this post. If you don’t watch the ridiculous dating show, consider yourself lucky. You probably spent your Monday night doing something productive or fun. And if you’re in the small minority who does watch the show but for some reason didn’t watch last night and you don’t want spoilers, you might want to click away now.

But if you’re interested in hearing my take on the final episode of Rachel Lindsay‘s search to find love, read on. (Side note: I hate the phrase “find love”. It makes it sound like love is an object that you can just happen upon while walking down the street).

I didn’t have much of a reaction to Eric being sent home. I just had this feeling that he wasn’t the one Rachel would choose. They had more of a friendship in my opinion. However, I agree with all of you who tweeted about how amazing his family was during the hometown visit, and how amazing his beard looked on last night’s live show. I also watched this interview former Bachelorette Ali did with Eric on her YouTube channel, and I love how positive he is. I’m sure he’ll find the right woman for him soon!

Moving on to the painful, heart wrenching, and at times infuriating section of the finale that was Rachel and Peter trying to come to terms with their difference of opinion on the idea of a proposal, and more specifically, a proposal that would hypothetically take place THE NEXT DAY.

I have to admit, I sided a bit more with Peter on this one. However, I could see where Rachel was coming from too. So I’ll make it simple and break out my understanding, and my thoughts, on each of their stances in this “argument”.

Peter’s Stance
Screen Shot 2017-08-08 at 12.56.49 PM
PC: @peterkrauswi

Peter is a realist and a bit of a cynic (something Rachel has actually called herself on multiple occasions). He is also fairly traditional, in the sense that he believes an engagement is essentially as important as the actual marriage. And he only wants to be engaged once in his life, and of course only wants to be married once in his life. One of the lines he said during the show was “being married doesn’t scare me, having multiple marriages scares me.” He really hit the nail on the head with that one. That’s such a universal fear. Everyone has the fantasy of being married one time and one time only.

With all that being said, Peter made it clear he saw a future with Rachel. He just didn’t feel ready to propose to her YET. He wanted more time for them to get to know each other in the “real world” before getting down on one knee and asking the question he feels is the most important of his life.

Rachel’s Stance
Screen Shot 2017-08-08 at 12.59.26 PM
PC: @therachellindsay

This is not Rachel’s first rodeo. She has been in plenty of serious relationships, and has even been on this show before. She knows what she wants, and what she wants is a proposal at the end of the show. Period. That is not something she is willing to compromise on. She also talked about a previous relationship where she was with him for 5 years expecting a proposal at some point, and it never came. So her biggest fear would be continuing to date Peter without him proposing, and then realizing it was never going to happen.

Rachel also views engagements a little differently than Peter. She thinks it’s okay to get engaged and then continue to get to know that person better before getting married. From what I understand, she thinks that if you know you want to be with that person, proposing is the next step in starting your life together.

My Stance

Like I said, I tend to side with Peter in this one, especially since we know the show is filmed over the course of a couple of months at the most. And when you really break it down, that only consists of about four actual one-on-one dates, and one overnight date. Would I expect someone to propose to me after that amount of time, especially considering the lack of alone time? Heck no!

I also think that a way Rachel and I differ in our opinions is that I believe it is possible to know you want to marry someone in the future, but still not be ready to take that step towards marriage right now. In my mind, if you’re going to spend the rest of your life with this person, what’s another couple of months, or years, to get to know them and build a strong foundation?

Screen Shot 2017-08-08 at 12.41.33 PM

With that being said, I also respect Rachel for knowing what she wants and going after it. I saw an interview with her where she said that in 4 years, she sees herself “married and with a couple kids.” She’s clearly in the phase of life where she’s ready to settle down and start a family, and she’s ready to start that life as soon as she can.

The heartbreaking part of this whole breakup was that I couldn’t help feeling that if this had all taken place in the “real world”, without the pressure of a proposal on a certain timeline, Rachel and Peter may have ended up together. Who knows, maybe all Peter needed was an extra month or two! But alas, this happened on a show where a proposal is expected, and where the lead of the show is certainly expecting it. So in the end, their difference of opinion, and Peter’s hesitation, was a deal breaker.

Screen Shot 2017-08-08 at 12.43.10 PM

Like the Eric elimination, I really didn’t have any strong feelings about Bryan “winning.” Honestly, the proposal itself was a little forgettable to me, and after all the Peter/Rachel drama, I just couldn’t really wrap my head around a proposal happening with someone else. I also didn’t like that the show spoiled that he won, by bringing out Peter and having him and Rachel discuss the breakup before the proposal had aired. It kinda felt like Bryan won “by default.”

With that being said, I will say that Bryan and Rachel clearly had great chemistry from the beginning, and he was someone I predicted would make it to the final two. And while he is not the type of man I would personally choose for myself, that doesn’t mean he isn’t right for Rachel. I really do wish them the best, and I hope they are truly happy together!

Screen Shot 2017-08-08 at 12.53.58 PM
PC: @thebacheloretteabc

What are your thoughts on last night’s finale? Did you predict she would choose Bryan, or were you shocked by the Peter breakup? Let me know in the comments! And don’t forget to follow me on Twitter to read back on all of my (sometimes sassy) thoughts from this season.



Posted by

Welcome to my blog! My name is Shelly, and I am a 20-something living in Austin, TX. I originally started this blog in 2014 during my semester abroad in Spain, and though I still enjoy writing about my travels, I mostly focus on lifestyle and wellness content. So if you are a 20-something who is looking for a blog you can relate to, this is it!

4 thoughts on “My Reaction to The Bachelorette Finale

  1. I said a lot of this on Ali’s blog but here you go.
    I get why Rachel is longing for a proposal- she doesn’t want a long term relationship that doesn’t end in marriage. Fine. But hijacking your current boyfriend of 2.5 months (and really only a week of actual time spent together?) into a proposal because that is the only way you will see commitment is crazy to me. Peter was always open and honest through the process and never gave the feeling that he wouldn’t propose at some point. She couldn’t even tell him that she was 100% committed to him. And he knows she has a strong connection to Bryan. Why should he be pressured into asking the important question? Even when he was- he was actually willing to propose to make her happy so they could stay together, she still didn’t see that as commitment because he wouldn’t really feel it.
    And now, she and Bryan are going to spend time getting to know each other. Uhhh- that’s exactly what Peter wanted to do! All this “I knew it was Bryan…Peter has issues” thing is just to cover up the fact that she had real feelings for Peter. It is for Bryan’s benefit.
    I wish her the best but I fear that she rushed into something with Bryan, who she may have great chemistry with but may not be forever material. Just because of a ring.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I agree with everything you said! Very well put. It was basically a crazy ultimatum, and if this had happened outside the show people would think she was crazy for demanding a proposal. And I was equally confused when she and Bryan said they are going to wait and get to know each other better before the wedding. That was literally all Peter wanted! I feel like she had a bit of a “I need it RIGHT NOW” attitude, but everyone knows most good things come with time and patience. I do hope we’re both wrong and she and Bryan will last, because I think she’s a great person, but I was definitely rubbed the wrong way by her behavior and actions in the finale/the live show (especially when she was so cold and sassy towards Peter for now reason!)


  2. I wanted Peter to be the one soooo bad. But I totally agree with everything you said. That being said, hopefully she really is happy and feels she made the right choice. Rachel is such a good person and I hope Bryan treats her right. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s